When young adults talk to me about their goals, I often hear "my parents", "my family" or "we" before I hear "I". There can be very little sense of what they want for themselves, as distinct from what was expected of them.
This is especially common in Asian families, where there can be heavy pressure to study hard, get into university and build a career in a respected field. This article looks at why that pressure exists, what it costs, and how to start working out your own goals without losing your family in the process.
Why your goals may really be your family's
Parents usually push for success for more than one reason. Part of it can be about how things look: a child in a respectable career is something parents can share with relatives, neighbours and friends. Part of it is care. A child who is well set up is a child parents no longer need to worry about, and that is a genuinely good goal in the long run.
Both motives can be present at once, and it helps to recognize the second one even when the first is frustrating. Most parents who push hard are trying to protect their children's future as they understand it.
What high family expectations cost
The difficulty is that a life built mainly around someone else's plan leaves little room to develop your own identity, your own goals, your own desires and your own relationships. Many of the young adults I work with feel strong guilt when their goals start to drift away from their parents', or when they want experiences that are just theirs.
Research on motivation helps explain why this is so uncomfortable. Self-determination theory identifies three basic psychological needs, autonomy, competence and relatedness, and finds that when these needs are thwarted, motivation and well-being suffer (Ryan & Deci, 2000). A young adult in this position is often caught between two of them: the need to choose their own direction, and the need to stay close to the people they love.
Filial piety, the Confucian idea of how children should treat their parents, is part of this picture. Research on the dual filial piety model has shown that it is neither simply good nor simply harmful: it can rest on affection and gratitude, or on hierarchy and obligation, and the two forms relate to wellbeing differently (Yeh & Bedford, 2003). Respecting your parents and having goals of your own are not opposites.
Working out what you want
In counselling, we start by separating the voices. When you describe a goal, whose words are you using, and what would you choose if nobody were watching? Often the answer is buried under years of expectation, and it takes time to hear it clearly.
I believe you already have the ability to reach your goals and find your own definition of success. My role is to help identify the barriers in the way, including guilt, fear of disappointing people, and beliefs about what you are allowed to want, and to work on removing them.
Talking to your parents without it becoming a fight
Every family is different, and some parents are so fixed on a particular path that some disagreement and discomfort are unavoidable. That does not mean it has to become a fight. It can be an open conversation.
The work is in learning how to approach the conversation: how to talk, how to listen, and how to build respect for autonomy on both sides. Sometimes it helps to bring parents into a counselling session, with the counsellor acting almost as a mediator. That gives parents a chance to hear their child properly, and to understand that a different goal is not the same as a plan to fail.
Why cutting family off is rarely the answer
I would caution against cutting your family off. Doing anything on your own is much harder than doing it with a support system around you, and the more support, love and kindness you have, the better your chances of reaching your goals. This is different where a family relationship is unsafe, and that is a conversation to have with a counsellor directly.
It also helps to be realistic. There is nothing wrong with going after a dream, but some career paths are harder to make work than others, and having a realistic backup plan is a good idea. Within that, you get one chance at your own life, and it is worth trying, every day, to be who you are and do what you actually want to do.
• • •
Commonly asked questions about expectations and independence
Is it normal to feel guilty for wanting something different from my parents? Yes. Guilt is very common when your own goals start to differ from your family's, especially in families where success is closely tied to obligation and respect.
How do I tell my parents I want a different career? It helps to prepare: be clear about what you want and why, listen to their concerns, and show that you have thought about a realistic plan. Some people find it useful to have that conversation with a counsellor present.
Can my parents come to a counselling session with me? In many cases, yes. A joint session can give both sides a structured, calmer space to be heard.
Should I cut contact with my family if they don't support my goals? For most people, keeping family relationships while setting boundaries works better than cutting contact, because support makes difficult goals easier to reach. Where a relationship is unsafe, the situation is different, and it is worth talking through with a professional.
What is filial piety? Filial piety is a Confucian value describing how children should respect and care for their parents. Research suggests it can be grounded in affection or in obligation, and those two forms affect wellbeing differently (Yeh & Bedford, 2003).
About Jordan Beatty
I am a registered clinical counsellor (RCC) based in Burnaby, BC. I work with youth and adults on anxiety, depression, stress, trauma, life transitions and substance use, in person in Burnaby, Vancouver, and online across British Columbia.
I am half Taiwanese and offer counselling in English and Mandarin. I have worked with young Asian men and women who came to counselling because of pressure around school, success and money, and I help them work on those goals and on the stress and low mood that often sit underneath.
I offer a free 20-minute consultation for you to get a sense of what it would be like to work with me, ask any questions you might have, and decide if we are the right fit.