Dream job or stable job: how to plan for both

Having a clear idea of what you want to do with your life gives you a sense of purpose and direction. But when circumstances get in the way of you pursuing that path, the gap between what you want and what you're actually doing can become a new source of frustration.

Research shows that people who feel drawn to a particular kind of work but never pursue it may be worse off than people who never felt drawn to anything. In a survey of 378 university faculty members, those with an unanswered calling reported poorer life satisfaction, job satisfaction and engagement, more work-related distress and more physical symptoms than people with no calling at all, while people with no calling fared about as well as those living out their calling (Gazica & Spector, 2015).

The study matches something I see often in young adults: the choice between a career they dream about and a job that feels safe can weigh on them for years. This article looks at why the choice becomes so hard, and how to plan in a way that keeps both doors open to you.

Why the choice feels impossible

The decision looks like a straight trade for many young adults. You can take a job with better pay that you do not enjoy, or work you love that does not pay much. Realistically, most people end up somewhere between the two. But at twenty years old, it can feel like a single decision that settles the rest of your life.

Family expectations often add weight to one side versus another. Where parents have pushed hard for a stable, respected career, choosing the dream can feel like a betrayal, and choosing the stable job can feel like giving up on yourself.

Going after the dream, with a backup plan

There is nothing wrong with going after your dream. You only get one chance to be who you are and to try to do what you actually want to do, and that is worth taking seriously.

At the same time, some career paths are harder to realistically make work than others, and having a backup plan is a good idea. A backup plan is a way of protecting the dream. It means a setback does not leave you with nothing, and it takes some of the fear out of trying.

In practice, planning for both might mean finishing a qualification that keeps a stable option open while building skills and experience in the field you care about, or setting a time frame for the dream and agreeing with yourself in advance what you will do if it has not worked by then.

A stable job can still be shaped

Choosing stability does not have to mean giving up on meaning. Research on job crafting describes how people reshape their work by changing the tasks they take on, the people they work with and the way they think about what the job is for, and how those changes alter both the meaning of the work and their sense of who they are at work (Wrzesniewski & Dutton, 2001).

A stable job can also fund and protect time for the thing you love, whether that is a creative project, a sport or study towards a later change of direction.

How to tell whether you are on the right path

In my view, the most useful test is a simple one. If you can get up in the morning and look forward to the day, work hard and feel accomplished, you are probably on the right path. Every job has days that are boring or frustrating. What matters is whether there are many more good days than bad ones, and whether you are still improving and working towards something.

Support matters too. The more support, encouragement and kindness you have around you, the better your chances of reaching your goals, whichever path you choose.

• • •

Commonly asked questions about chasing a dream job or a stable job

Should I follow my dream or take a stable job? For many people the best answer is a plan that includes both: pursuing the dream with a realistic backup in place. That way a setback does not leave you without options.

Is it a mistake to choose money over passion? Not necessarily. A stable job can be shaped over time to include more meaningful work, and it can support interests outside work (Wrzesniewski & Dutton, 2001).

What if my parents want me to choose the stable option? It helps to understand their reasons, explain yours, and show them you have a realistic plan. Some people find it useful to have that conversation with a counsellor's help.

How do I know if I have chosen the right career? A useful sign is having more good days than bad ones, and feeling that you are improving and working towards something. No job feels exciting every day.

Can counselling help with career decisions? Yes. Counselling can help you sort out what you want from what is expected of you, manage the anxiety around the decision, and make a plan you can act on.

• • •

About Jordan Beatty

I am a registered clinical counsellor (RCC) based in Burnaby, BC. I work with youth and adults on anxiety, depression, stress, trauma, life transitions and substance use, in person in Burnaby, Vancouver, and online across British Columbia.

I am half Taiwanese and offer counselling in English and Mandarin. I have worked with young Asian men and women who came to counselling because of pressure around school, success and money, and I help them work on those goals and on the stress and low mood that often sit underneath.

I offer a free 20-minute consultation for you to get a sense of what it would be like to work with me, ask any questions you might have, and decide if we are the right fit.

Previous
Previous

Why big goals make you feel stuck, and how to break them down

Next
Next

Separating your parents' goals from your own: guilt, family expectations, and finding what you actually want