It's easy to feel like you're falling behind everyone else when the people around you seem to be reaching milestones you haven't reached yet. This is especially true when you’re young. Even when you do feel satisfied with your own progress, seeing what others have achieved online can make you question where you stand and whether you’ve made the right decisions or worked hard enough.
Its common for people judge how they are doing largely by comparing themselves with others. Psychologist Leon Festinger proposed this idea in 1954 as social comparison theory: when there is no objective standard to measure ourselves against, we look to the people around us (Festinger, 1954).
Social media has made access to those comparisons constantly available. Instead of measuring yourself against a few classmates or coworkers in your circle, you can now compare yourself, at any hour, with hundreds of people's curated best moments like getting the job offer, going on the big trip, getting engaged, making big progress at the gym, or anything else that seems particularly important to you.
For many teens and young adults, that steady stream of other people's highlights leaves them feeling behind or even lost.
What the research shows
Research suggests that social media can affect how people feel about themselves, particularly from the lens of comparing their lives to those of others.
One study found that people who used Facebook more frequently tended to have lower overall self-esteem, partly because they were more likely to compare themselves with people they perceived as doing better. The researchers also found that simply viewing profiles that encouraged these comparisons could temporarily lower self-esteem (Vogel et al., 2014).
The way people use social media also makes a big difference. A study by Verduyn et al. (2015) found that passively scrolling through Facebook, rather than actively posting or communicating with others, could reduce people's sense of well-being over time.
There is also evidence that spending less time on social media can improve your mental health. In a study involving 143 university students, participants who limited their use of Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat to 10 minutes per platform each day for three weeks actually reported less loneliness and fewer symptoms of depression than those who continued using social media as usual (Hunt et al., 2018).
The findings of this research suggest that how people engage with social media matters as much as how often they use it. Spending time looking at other people's lives, particularly when those lives appear more successful or fulfilling, can have a negative effect on mood and self-esteem for many people.
If we think about how social media has evolved since these studies were done in the 2010s and how much more engaging it now is, we can expect that these effects are even more heightened.
Why comparisons hit teens and young adults harder
Teenagehood and early adulthood are full of open questions about who you are, what you’ll study, what career you’ll do, and your relationships, money, and where you live. There is rarely a clear standard for whether you are on track or even on the right path. That is exactly the situation in which, according to Festinger, people lean most on comparison to others.
For many young adults, comparison did not start with social media but in families where success is closely watched and children were measured against cousins, classmates, and neighbours' children from an early age. Social media can be a continuation of that, with a far larger audience, and a larger group of people to compare yourself to.
And besides that, being young is simply tough on its own, so comparing yourself to others who seem to have it “under control” can make you feel even more lost at a time when you’re not supposed to necessarily have all the answers.
What you are actually comparing
A feed usually shows only the best few moments of other people's lives. These moments have been chosen and edited carefully. Your own life, by contrast, you see in full. You see the boring days, the doubts, the things that did not work, the awkward social interactions, all of it. Comparing your whole life with someone else's highlights will almost always make yours look worse.
A fairer measure is your own progress. Are you having more good days than bad ones? Are you improving at something that matters to you? Have you found things you are passionate about? Those questions have answers you can act on, which "am I as successful as them" rarely does.
What actually helps
Pay attention to how social media affects your mood. Think about how you feel after spending time on Instagram, TikTok, or other platforms. If certain accounts consistently make you feel inadequate or unhappy with your own life, consider unfollowing them.
Spend more time interacting with people. Use social media to stay in touch with friends rather than spending most of your time scrolling. Research suggests that actively communicating with others has different effects on well-being than passively viewing their posts (Verduyn et al., 2015).
Reduce the time you spend scrolling. Try setting a daily limit or taking breaks from social media. One study found that limiting use to 30 minutes a day reduced loneliness and depressive symptoms among university students (Hunt et al., 2018).
Pay more attention to your own progress. Instead of measuring your achievements against what other people post online, think about where you were six months or a year ago. Consider what has improved in your life and what you still want to work towards.
When comparison becomes something heavier
Sometimes comparison is a symptom of something underneath it: low self-esteem, anxiety, depression, or a long-held belief that you are only worth as much as you achieve. In counselling, I approach these feelings without judgment, and work with clients to understand where they come from and what is getting in the way of feeling settled in their own lives.
• • •
Commonly asked questions about comparing yourself to others online
Why does social media make me feel bad about myself? Research suggests frequent upward comparison, measuring yourself against people who seem to be doing better, is linked to lower self-esteem (Vogel et al., 2014). Passive scrolling in particular has been linked to lower mood through envy (Verduyn et al., 2015).
Does limiting social media improve mental health? In one experiment, students who limited social media to about 30 minutes a day for three weeks reported less loneliness and depression (Hunt et al., 2018). Even smaller reductions may be worth trying.
Is it normal to compare myself to others? Yes. Comparing ourselves with others is a basic way people judge how they are doing (Festinger, 1954). It becomes a problem when it is constant and consistently leaves you feeling worse.
How do I stop comparing myself to others online? Notice which accounts affect your mood, reduce passive scrolling, and set daily limits. Measuring progress against your own past rather than other people's highlights also helps.
Can counselling help with low self-esteem? Yes. Counselling can help you understand where low self-esteem comes from and build a steadier sense of your own worth.
• • •
About Jordan Beatty
I am a registered clinical counsellor (RCC) based in Burnaby, BC. I work with youth and adults on anxiety, depression, stress, trauma, life transitions and substance use, in person in Burnaby, Vancouver, and online across British Columbia.
I work with teens and young adults who come to counselling because of pressure around school, success and money, and others things. I help them work on the goals, stress, and low mood that often sit underneath.
I offer a free 20-minute consultation for you to get a sense of what it would be like to work with me, ask any questions you might have, and decide if we are the right fit.