Young Asian men and counselling: why so many wait, and what a first session is like

Asian Canadians use mental health services less often than white Canadians. An analysis of the Canadian Community Health Survey found that white respondents were more likely to have used mental health services than Chinese, South Asian and South East Asian respondents, and that among people without major depression, Chinese respondents appeared to be the least likely to have done so (Tiwari & Wang, 2008).

The pattern is similar in the United States. In a national study of more than 2,000 Asian Americans, about 8.6% had used any mental health-related service in the previous year, and only 34.1% of those with a probable mental health diagnosis had sought any help (Abe-Kim et al., 2007).


Why stigma keeps young Asian men away from counselling

In Taiwan, China and many other Asian countries, mental health problems are often treated as something shameful, something to hide rather than acknowledge. When someone in the family has a mental illness, the family may keep it out of sight so that nobody outside the home finds out. Many young people grow up hearing a simple instruction from their parents: don't tell anyone, and don't talk to anyone about it.

In my experience, that silence makes things worse over time. Problems that could have been talked about early are carried alone, possible for years, and the shame attached to them grows rather than fades.

And, research even supports the link between cultural values and help-seeking. In a study of 242 Asian American university students, those who held more strongly to traditional Asian cultural values had less positive attitudes toward professional psychological help and were less willing to see a counsellor (Kim & Omizo, 2003).


Where being a man comes in

Gender adds an additional second layer. Researchers studying men's help-seeking have described how expectations many men grow up with, such as self-reliance and keeping emotions under control, make asking for help even harder, and how the setting and framing of help affect whether men use it (Addis & Mahalik, 2003).

For a young Asian man, these two sets of expectations can stack on top of each other. Needing counselling can feel like a failure of character and a source of embarrassment for the family at the same time, and a lot of fear builds up around what it would mean to need help at all.


What usually brings young Asian men to counselling

In the young Asian men I have worked with, the reason for coming in is often something other than mental health on the surface. It rather tends to be about the things that are most highly valued: money, success, grades, school and the stress that comes with all of them. Only occasionally is the first conversation about mental health itself.

That is a perfectly good place to start. There is nothing wrong with coming to counselling with the goal of doing better, whether that means academic success, career success or financial stability. Counselling is a place to work towards those goals, and the stress, pressure and low mood that often sit underneath them usually come into view along the way.


What a first session is like

A first session is usually calm, and its main purpose is to get acquainted. You do not have to arrive with a diagnosis or the right words. You talk about what you are thinking, how you are feeling and what you want to change, at whatever pace feels manageable.

My priority in a first session with clients is that they feel safe and comfortable enough to share what is on their mind. I approach clients with a neutral, non-judgmental lens: my job is to understand why something happened, not to judge that it happened.


If you are on the fence

Getting extra help for your mental health is no different from getting extra tutoring, or doing extra reading before a test. It is a way of giving yourself a better chance. Left alone for too long, mental health difficulties can drag down school, work and relationships, which are often the very things you care most about.

Counsellors go to counselling too. Nobody has perfect mental health, and there is nothing to be ashamed of in looking after yours.

• • •

Commonly asked questions about counselling and young Asian men

Why do Asian Canadians use mental health services less?
Canadian survey data show lower use of mental health services among Chinese, South Asian and South East Asian respondents than among white respondents (Tiwari & Wang, 2008). Stigma, family expectations of privacy, and cultural values around self-reliance are among the reasons research and clinical experience point to.

Can I go to counselling for stress about school, work or money?
Yes. Many people start counselling because of academic, career or financial pressure, and those are legitimate reasons to come in.

Will my family find out I am seeing a counsellor?
Counselling is confidential, with a small number of legal exceptions that your counsellor will explain at the start. Whether and when to tell your family is your decision to make.

What happens in the first counselling session?
The first session is mainly for getting acquainted and making sure you feel comfortable. You can share as much or as little as you want, and together we work out what you would like to focus on.

Do I need to have a mental illness to see a counsellor?
No. People come to counselling to better understand and cope with stress, pressure, relationships, decisions and many other reasons, without any diagnosis.

• • •

About Jordan Beatty

I am a registered clinical counsellor (RCC) based in Burnaby, BC. I work with youth and adults on anxiety, depression, stress, trauma, life transitions and substance use, in person in Burnaby, Vancouver, and online across British Columbia.

I am half Taiwanese and offer counselling in English and Mandarin. I have worked with young Asian men who came to counselling because of pressure around school, success and money, and I help them work on those goals and on the stress and low mood that often sit underneath.

I offer a free 20-minute consultation for you to get a sense of what it would be like to work with me, ask any questions you might have, and decide if we are the right fit.

Previous
Previous

Finding direction when you don't have a clear passion